-
Popular choice
Kenny'S Tipperary Inn
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Golf centre
- Heated swimming pool
The inn is also situated merely a 9-minute walk from Gosman's Dock.
Shadmoor State Ocean Park is reachable within a 10-minute ride.
Guests can take advantage of a separate toilet, a shower, and a rainfall showerhead, along with hair dryers and bath sheets supplied in the bathrooms. The spacious rooms include views of the pool.
Kenny'S Tipperary Inn
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Golf centre
- Heated swimming pool
Kenny'S Tipperary Inn
The inn is also situated merely a 9-minute walk from Gosman's Dock.
Shadmoor State Ocean Park is reachable within a 10-minute ride.
Guests can take advantage of a separate toilet, a shower, and a rainfall showerhead, along with hair dryers and bath sheets supplied in the bathrooms. The spacious rooms include views of the pool.
Cheshire Welcome Inn
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Luggage storage
- Garden area
Cheshire Welcome Inn
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Luggage storage
- Garden area
Cheshire Welcome Inn
Carrier Motor Lodge
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Flat-screen TV
- Laundry
- Vending machines
- Jacuzzi
Carrier Motor Lodge
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Flat-screen TV
- Laundry
- Vending machines
- Jacuzzi
Carrier Motor Lodge
Cheap Motels in Shelter Island
Clinton Motel
- Picnic area/ Tables
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Outdoor swimming pool
Clinton Motel
- Picnic area/ Tables
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Outdoor swimming pool
Clinton Motel
-
Guest favorite
-
Beach access
Aqualina Inn Montauk (Adults Only)
- Picnic area/ Tables
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Live entertainment
- Saltwater pool
The centre of Montauk is a 10 minutes' walk of the motel. Air & Speed is approximately 500 metres from this Montauk hotel, while Hither Hills is 4.4 km away.
Right around the corner from the Aqualina Montauk you'll find Kirk Park Beach.
Along with a flat-screen TV with satellite channels, the allergy-friendly rooms offer coffee/tea making facilities, and private bathrooms with a walk-in shower and a separate toilet.
Aqualina Inn Montauk (Adults Only)
- Picnic area/ Tables
- Free parking
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Live entertainment
- Saltwater pool
Aqualina Inn Montauk (Adults Only)
The centre of Montauk is a 10 minutes' walk of the motel. Air & Speed is approximately 500 metres from this Montauk hotel, while Hither Hills is 4.4 km away.
Right around the corner from the Aqualina Montauk you'll find Kirk Park Beach.
Along with a flat-screen TV with satellite channels, the allergy-friendly rooms offer coffee/tea making facilities, and private bathrooms with a walk-in shower and a separate toilet.
Montauk Oceanside Suites
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- Air conditioning
- Ironing facilities
- Heating
- Golf centre
Hither Hills is just a few steps from this Montauk motel, while Air & Speed is just 500 metres away. Besides, Fort Pond Bay Park is nearly a 25-minute walk away.
The area also includes natural sites like Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course, which are 2.7 km from the Oceanside Montauk.
Montauk Oceanside Suites
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- Air conditioning
- Ironing facilities
- Heating
- Golf centre
Montauk Oceanside Suites
Hither Hills is just a few steps from this Montauk motel, while Air & Speed is just 500 metres away. Besides, Fort Pond Bay Park is nearly a 25-minute walk away.
The area also includes natural sites like Montauk Downs State Park Golf Course, which are 2.7 km from the Oceanside Montauk.
Pet friendly Motels in Shelter Island
Liberty Inn Old Saybrook
- Free parking
- Security
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Ironing facilities
- Tea and coffee facilities
Liberty Inn Old Saybrook
- Free parking
- Security
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Ironing facilities
- Tea and coffee facilities
Liberty Inn Old Saybrook
Red Roof Inn Milford - New Haven
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Laundry
- Ironing facilities
Red Roof Inn Milford - New Haven
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Laundry
- Ironing facilities
Red Roof Inn Milford - New Haven
-
Top location
-
Beach access
Southold Beach Motel
- Picnic area/ Tables
- Free parking
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Sun terrace
Southold Beach Motel
- Picnic area/ Tables
- Free parking
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Sun terrace
Southold Beach Motel
Family friendly Motels in Shelter Island
Budget Host East End Riverhead
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Heating
- Outdoor swimming pool
Budget Host East End Riverhead
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Heating
- Outdoor swimming pool
Budget Host East End Riverhead
-
Best-rated
-
Private beach
Hartman'S Briney Breezes Beach Resort
- BBQ facilities
-
Car park
Charges may apply
- Concierge desk
- Air conditioning
- Golf centre
- Pool with view
In proximity to the motel you will reach Camp Hero State Park.
No matter the religion, travellers prefer to visit Saint Therese of Lisieux Church, a popular place of worship located 2.3 km from this Montauk hotel.
Some rooms also boast sea views.
Hartman'S Briney Breezes Beach Resort
- BBQ facilities
-
Car park
Charges may apply
- Concierge desk
- Air conditioning
- Golf centre
- Pool with view
Hartman'S Briney Breezes Beach Resort
In proximity to the motel you will reach Camp Hero State Park.
No matter the religion, travellers prefer to visit Saint Therese of Lisieux Church, a popular place of worship located 2.3 km from this Montauk hotel.
Some rooms also boast sea views.
-
Great deal
Windsor Motel
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Ironing facilities
- Heating
Windsor Motel
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Ironing facilities
- Heating
Windsor Motel
Popular Motels in Shelter Island
Red Roof Inn Meriden - Ct
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Ironing facilities
- Fitness centre
Located near a train station, the motel is merely a 13-minute walk from Saint Johns Field. Giuffrida Memorial Outdoor Center YMCA Sports Complex is an about 3 km away.
The private bathrooms have a walk-in shower and a separate toilet, along with comforts such as hairdryers and bath sheets.
Red Roof Inn Meriden - Ct
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Ironing facilities
- Fitness centre
Red Roof Inn Meriden - Ct
Located near a train station, the motel is merely a 13-minute walk from Saint Johns Field. Giuffrida Memorial Outdoor Center YMCA Sports Complex is an about 3 km away.
The private bathrooms have a walk-in shower and a separate toilet, along with comforts such as hairdryers and bath sheets.
Tower Inn And Suites Of Guilford / Madison
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Ironing facilities
- Tea and coffee facilities
- Heating
Tower Inn And Suites Of Guilford / Madison
- Free parking
- 24-hour reception
- Air conditioning
- Ironing facilities
- Tea and coffee facilities
- Heating
Tower Inn And Suites Of Guilford / Madison
-
Beach access
White Sands Motel
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Sun loungers
You can find Victor D'Amico Institute of Art a short way from the 3-star hotel.
Also, this accommodation is 4 km from Hither Hills State Park.
The rooms are equipped with coffee and tea makers, along with a flat-screen TV with satellite channels for guests' comfort. These rooms here offer private bathrooms. Bathrooms include a separate toilet and a shower, and such comforts as a shower cap and towels. The White Sands offers rooms which overlook the sea.
White Sands Motel
- BBQ facilities
- Free parking
- Housekeeping
- Air conditioning
- Flat-screen TV
- Sun loungers
White Sands Motel
You can find Victor D'Amico Institute of Art a short way from the 3-star hotel.
Also, this accommodation is 4 km from Hither Hills State Park.
The rooms are equipped with coffee and tea makers, along with a flat-screen TV with satellite channels for guests' comfort. These rooms here offer private bathrooms. Bathrooms include a separate toilet and a shower, and such comforts as a shower cap and towels. The White Sands offers rooms which overlook the sea.
Modern Motels in Shelter Island
-
Private beach
Ocean View Terrace
- In-room breakfast
-
Car park
Charges may apply
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Golf centre
- Pool with view
Guests can get to Shinnecock Nation Cultural Center and Museum that is 4.9 km from the 3-star hotel.
The rooms include coffee/tea making machines, along with complimentary wireless internet and a flat-screen TV with satellite channels for your convenience. These air-conditioned rooms are equipped with separate bathrooms. Bathrooms with a walk-in shower and a separate toilet, also offer hair dryers and towels. The rooms also look onto the pool.
Ocean View Terrace
- In-room breakfast
-
Car park
Charges may apply
- VIP check-in/ -out
- Air conditioning
- Golf centre
- Pool with view
Ocean View Terrace
Guests can get to Shinnecock Nation Cultural Center and Museum that is 4.9 km from the 3-star hotel.
The rooms include coffee/tea making machines, along with complimentary wireless internet and a flat-screen TV with satellite channels for your convenience. These air-conditioned rooms are equipped with separate bathrooms. Bathrooms with a walk-in shower and a separate toilet, also offer hair dryers and towels. The rooms also look onto the pool.
Are you in a hurry?
Here is a quick list of hotels in Shelter Island, selected based on their rating
| Name of hotel | Accommodation Rating | Price, $ | |
| Kenny'S Tipperary Inn |
8.2 / 10 (603 Reviews) |
From 99$ | |
| Cheshire Welcome Inn |
7.7 / 10 (463 Reviews) |
From 85$ | |
| Carrier Motor Lodge |
7.9 / 10 (292 Reviews) |
From 70$ | |
| Clinton Motel |
8.5 / 10 (238 Reviews) |
From 102$ | |
| Aqualina Inn Montauk (Adults Only) |
9.0 / 10 (283 Reviews) |
From 285$ |
Frequently Asked Questions
Which affordable motels in Shelter Island are best for beach access?
Hartman's Briney Breezes Beach Resort and Kenny's Tipperary Inn are both great options. They offer direct access to the beach and family-friendly accommodations for a fun getaway.
Book your stay during weekdays in early September for better rates and fewer crowds at the beach.
What motels in Shelter Island offer family rooms?
Montauk Oceanside Suites and White Sands Motel provide spacious family rooms. These options come with kitchenettes, making them ideal for family meals.
Look for rooms with two-bedroom configurations, especially during summer, for maximum comfort for larger families.
Which pet-friendly motels in Shelter Island are available?
Kenny's Tipperary Inn is a notable pet-friendly option where you can bring your furry friends along on vacation. It's located near many outdoor attractions ideal for walking your pet.
Call ahead to confirm pet policies and avoid extra fees, especially during busy summer weekends.
Which motels near downtown Shelter Island are convenient for sightseeing?
Cheshire Welcome Inn and Carrier Motor Lodge are both conveniently located near local attractions. You can explore nearby parks and restaurants on foot with ease.
Visit nearby Sleeping Giant State Park in the early morning for fewer crowds and cooler hiking conditions.
Where can I find motels in Shelter Island with hot tubs?
The Cheshire Welcome Inn has hot tubs available for guests. It's an excellent way to relax after a day of exploring local attractions.
Book a room that includes access to the hot tub during off-peak hours for a quieter experience.
Which motels near Montauk Downs State Park are great for outdoor activities?
White Sands Motel and Ocean View Terrace are perfect for visitors wanting outdoor adventures. You can easily access activities at Montauk Downs State Park from these hotels.
Try to visit the park early in the day for calmer hiking trails, especially during weekends.
Which motels in Shelter Island offer breakfast options?
The Liberty Inn Old Saybrook provides breakfast for guests. This is a convenient option for starting your day before heading out to explore the island.
Try to arrive early for breakfast to enjoy a wider variety of fresh options before they run out.
What unique activities can I enjoy in Shelter Island during winter?
In winter, the area offers beautiful trails for hiking, and some motels provide cozy hot tubs for relaxation. It can be a peaceful time to enjoy nature without the crowds.
Pack warm clothing and waterproof shoes for hiking, particularly around the shoreline during winter months for stunning views.
Can I find shopping options close to motels in Shelter Island?
Many motels like the Cheshire Welcome Inn are located near shopping districts, where you can find local boutiques and restaurants. This adds convenience for guests looking to explore.
Visit the shops during weekday afternoons to find the best selection with fewer crowds.
How can I get around Shelter Island efficiently?
Biking and walking are the best ways to explore Shelter Island. Many motels are within easy reach of popular attractions, making them perfect for getting around.
Rent bikes from local vendors, especially in the spring and fall, to enjoy mild weather while exploring the island's scenic routes.